Colosseo in Port Jefferson Station

Best pizza hands down I've ever had. Next door to DMV. Makes you look forward to going to DMV just to get a slice.

I have been loving Colosseo pizza since elementary school and to date its still top on my list! Now living in Nassau County I get the craving and make the drive out to enjoy a great slice of a pie.

Absolutely the worst pizza. Unfriendly people behind the counter. No reason to go there

Cash only !!!! But amazing pizza and that's really all they have couple of salad options. Awesome pizza though !!!

I've been coming here since I was a kid and the pizza is always good and the workers are always kind and respectful

Probably the best Sicilian pizza I've ever had and ever will have. There's something about their sauce that makes it irresistibly good, I wish I could buy it and use it at home. Their pizza is always worth the wait

My favorite pizza in the country! I live in VT now and dream of this food...

Best Grandma Pizza in Suffolk County!! Their salads and gourmet pizza are always fresh! Service very prompt and courteous! —Dr. Andrew Linick, Restaurant Critic, Practical Gourmet(Tm) mag. Chairman: Gold taste dining awards(Tm)

Best pizza and garlic knots around.just wish they delivered and I'd order there every week!

Classic NY pizza; the good stuff. You’ll fine everything you need to have a big Italian pizza party in this fine establishment. Don’t come looking for elegance, extravagance or the elaborate hipster concoction. All you need is a big greasy sicilian pie (toppings optional) to find your happy place in Pizzatown USA. And for the lactose averse/intolerant, they make a pretty mean salad pie too.

Best pizza in port Jefferson station. Staff friendly. Been going here for as long as I can remember. Definitely recommend this place

AAA service , pizza was amazing!!

Do I really need to say anything about this place? Just get the Sicilian and enjoy. Best pizza around outside of NYC IMO.

We ordered during the covid pandemic and could not have been happier with our order ! The pizza was delicious and the service and safety (contactless curbside) was great as well ! I hope to continue to see this small business thrive !! Thank you :)

Best pizza in the neighborhood

I love them going 38 yrs

Some of best pizza on LI. Waiter gave great service.

The best pizza imo. A must have ones a week. Grilled chicken salad is excellent. Servers are always friendly and helpful. We love it here

Best pizza you can get, old school

I grew up eating Colosseo pizza and have yet to find pizza that even comes close to the perfection of Colosseo. I have since moved off the Island, and no longer eat pizza because no one else makes it right! I always make sure to stop in and get my pizza fix when I visit the Island. What a blessing to be able to visit the Island and once again enjoy a couple slices of THE BEST PIZZA EVER!!! Also, got to bring my husband here for the first time and he LOVED IT!!! He said it was better than he expected, especially the Sicilian Pie! ♥️🍕♥️I’ll be back, Colosseo, I’ll be back! ♥️🍕♥️

Best new York pizza in the state try them u will see wow!!!!!

Great pizza! 🍕

This is *THE BEST* pizza I have ever had on Long Island. When you come here it's like you're family. If you haven't tried it, do it! You won't be disappointed.

Have been coming here for decades.This restaurant may make the best pizza on Long Island.Moved to Florida and nothing comes close to the taste and quality of their pizza.When we visit we always stop here for a few slices.Will be back again in a few months.Great food

Grew up on their pizza and I live in Pennsylvania now and I would drive there for their sicilian alone love the place and been there for years!

This place has the best Sicilian slice but when you come here it's cash only no card payment

Nice clean large place, family or solo casual setting. Has a pizza bar upfront across from counter and a self serv/ sit nice lit dining area. Staff waiters were very polite, tables get clean quick. A little pricey but pizza was good. The bottom of my pepperoni was a lil burnt tho, only reason for 4 stars.

Never a bad slice...maybe the best in Suffolk

Pizza and pinwheels were very good. Decent area inside to sit down and eat.

Excellent pizza! Try the Sicilian it's easily one of the best on the island. Clean and sharp looking restaurant. Service was good

One of the best pizza places on Long island. They've been around for over 30 years. You can sit in and dine or just take out. Nice staff, quick service. Highly recommend!

One of the best pizza in the world. Amazing cheese taste & excellently done in brick oven. Very good service. Lots of waiting on the weekend. So either go there in the afternoon or go a little early in the evening.

I used to love coming to this pizza place always said it was the best pizza around, but they need to upgrade some of their older staff, very rude...

BEST pizza ANYWHERE! I've been going here for 40+ years! Salad with mozzarella on top is practically addiction! Awesome staff too! Family friendly. I believe it's cash only?

Nice staff and good pizza.

If you're going to do one thing in life ,make it the best. Such is the case with Colosseo.. they only make pizza and it's the best. Our favorites are the salad pizza which is the best we've ever had.. crispy and FRESH with a great Italian dressing. My personal favorite is the Grandma pie. I just tried the special which is amazing if you want a huge meal on one slice. Important to note that Colosseo only accepts and for that it costs them a star. The place gets jammed so order ahead if our picking up or go early if your staying.

Recently ordered a grandma's pie and regular pie. I was so disappointed. The grandma's pie had a regular pizza crust with cheese and a small circle of sauce in the middle. That is not a grandma's pizza. Plus a dozen garlic knots and 2 slices of salad pizza. For $52.00 the quality could have been better.

Another disappointing pizza cold and burnt during the pandemic. Customer service for take out has gotten worse as well. Time to find a new place for me

The pizza is not what it used to be and the Hispanic girls behind the counter are extremely rude and condescending. There's other place nearby for better pizza and better service. Avoid.

Hands down the best pizza you will get in the area, also their salads are amazing.

I grew up eating Colosseo pizza and after 28 years of living and trying pizza from sooo many places, this is still my absolute favorite! I live in Cali for now, but everytime I come home to visit, everyone knows I need to make at LEAST 1 stop at Colosseo's. They are cash only, but the peices are great and the quality is SUPERB! The salads are super fresh 😋 If you're coming from out of state, get the garlic knots too 😉

Best pizza in town.. this place has been around for Years and it's not hard to tell why.. they are fast and friendly. The waiter service was exceptional. Johnny was our server and he was incredible. He waited on the entire back room alone during a peak lunch time crowd and he didnt miss a beat. He was fast, polite and precise, a real professional. I will be getting pizza from here anytime I'm in town!

best pizza of my life, every time

I tried this spot before with a friend and I am addicted since then. I enjoyed the awesome character and flavorful dishes and beverages. Kudos.

I grew up down the road from colosseo and have been eating there literally my entire life. Its without a doubt in the top 3 pizza places I've ever been to, and that includes all the burroughs of NY.I left NY a few years ago and this has become my first stop every single time I come back to the island. I seriously miss it.Never had a bad slice or a bad experience, and I'm super confused by some people complaining about rude employees. I've probably been in there hundreds of times and have never had anyone be the slightest bit condescending or rude to me.

Very good pizza. Cheese was tasty and delicious and not salty. We. always enjoy it. How did you know we went there since we paid cash?

This is hands down the best pizza in the area. And if you want a great house said, this is definitely the place!

People who work there are not nice,and the mama's pizza is the only good pie they have

This place is not what it used to be! The quality of the pizza is VERY inconsistent! The service is the worst. Very rude workers. The pizza used to be worth it, but not anymore. Not fresh.. But the workers have such attitude it’s always a problem. We are regulars too, couple times a week. Such a shame. Will be looking for a new spot.